From a press release announcing a new format for the Women’s Profesional Soccer league All-Star game:
"All 36 players will then travel to Atlanta. In Atlanta, the two captains together with the team coaches will select the Starting XI for each team in an alternating “playground pick-em” style format during a public event in the days prior to the WPS All-Star Game."
Can’t find the column, but Simmons suggested this format for the NBA All-Star Game at some point.